Dialing in prop/pitch can’t be done without a functioning tach. And before you spend the time and money on tearing down that motor I’d highly suggest replacing it with more HP. You will experience significant hull performance issues with an 85hp hung on a 19’6. Sluggish would be an understatement.
If you're just looking for a decent/cheap starting point so you can safely run your motor this summer, the prop wizard for Turning Point would not be a bad place to start. Maybe lean towards a little more pitch so you don't fry your motor with unknown high RPMs. But to do it right you definitely need a tach.Ditto on the power on your 19'6. I have an 85 two stroke on my 170, and I'd say it's on the smaller end of perfect. 19-6 is a lot more boat though.However, with the right prop, you may be able to happily cruise around in the low 20s; if that's good enough for you and you don't want to repower, then run with it and get out on the water!