So reading Cale's rebuild get me thinking (which can often be dangerous lol) and since I had everything laying around in the shop already I decided to set up a small test to see if it would be worth while to set up a mold for making floor panels.
I took a spare piece of 1/4" melamine and put a layer of wax on it and then brushed on some gelcoat and let that kick for about a half hour. Then I came back and added a layer of mat, 2 layers of 1700, and another layer of mat. I then rolled that out to get rid of any air bubbles and excess resin and laid in a scrap piece of coosa and a scrap piece of foam and weighted them down.
After about an hour it felt pretty solid so I pulled the battery off and peeled it up. The gelcoat around the edges came right up but it did stick a little bit right in the center. I am guessing that was from the heat and pressure and probably would have come up easier had I used a few more layers of wax and/or PVA. I trimmed them up with the angle grinder and was very impressed overall. They are as smooth as glass.
This was with very minimal sanding mainly to remove the stuck pieces of melamine. The next time I try it I will definitely use more wax and PVA to help it release cleaner, and go a little thicker on the gelcoat. I may let it cure a little longer too to see if that helps it release cleaner.
Again, this was just a small scale test so I am happy to hear any comments you may have to make it easier the next time. Hopefully someone finds this useful and can minimize (not eliminate) their fairing time.