Thanks for the reply. My Johnny 225 burns the same (16-18gph). Most of the DI 2 strokes and 4 strokes are 9-10gph at 4000rpm. Mercury's web site has some good test info. Check the 225 and 250 Optimax numbers, you might be surprised.
Look very closely at the shift shaft on your motor. Unless it was already replaced, it's not stainless steel. Motors of that vintage are known to have the shift shaft break which prevents your from going in/out of gear. Replacing it required powerhead removal and can be very expensive.