Your old 150 Mariners are right at 425 lbs. They published 405, but that was a short leg model. And the Yamaha 4 cylinder 150/175 are 480 lbs. each. The price of the Yammies is an OUCH!
You might want to consider a pair of Mercury Pro XS 150-175. These are fast, V-6., 2 stroke injected engines. Weight is pretty close (430 lbs) and you can use the same controls and gauges (or switch to Smartgauge and keep the same controls). You can get 2 of these for a little more than 1 Yamaha. The Mercury 4 stroke 150 is another choice and you still use your old controls - it's 455 lbs each.
Another option would be the Suzuki DF150-175 four cylinder 4 stroke motors. These are about 470 lbs each - move the batteries up under the console and you should offset the stern weight. Price is about right - more than the Mercs, but less than the Yammie.
So set your priorities - wanna go fast with little maintenance? Go with the Merc 2-strokes. Want better fuel economy and not have to pay an arm and a couple legs? Zukis might be the answer. But check the prices for new controls/gauges too! Only downside to Zuki is their limited service and parts system.
Wanna spend some bucks? Get the Yammies! You will need new controls and gauges that are also pricey. Also - you may want to look into the recent problems with Yamaha corrosion...