Fixed it!
Thanks all for the suggestions. Pulled the toggle panel back and figured out that the feed wire was disconnected somehow. Interestingly, many of the other red connections are zipped in but that one was missing a zip. No longer - reattached and zipped and now the toggles are working fine again!
Of course now I see that my float switch on the bilge is not working... always something...
For reference, here is the pic of the instrument panel pulled back. The incoming feed is circled in red.